Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Paid link

Storage · 4 picks compared

Best External Hard Drive for Time Machine Backup (2026): 4 Picks Compared

We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

It connects by USB 3.0, recognizes Mac computers automatically, and needs reformatting for Time Machine. The two Western Digital 2TB drives suit smaller backup sets, and the 4TB Seagate Expansion Desktop sits between them on capacity.

Your shortlist at a glance

PCKitHQ scores range from 9.2 to 9.8. See how we pick.

Product and key specificationsScore and retailer
01Seagate Expansion
Best Overall

Seagate Expansion

24TB

9.8PCKitHQ
score
View on Amazon
02WD 2TB My Passport Ultra9.6PCKitHQ
score
View on Amazon
03WD 2TB My Passport
Also Consider

WD 2TB My Passport

2TB

9.4PCKitHQ
score
View on Amazon
04Seagate Expansion Desktop9.2PCKitHQ
score
View on Amazon

A closer look at each configuration

1
Best Overall

Seagate Expansion

9.8PCKitHQ
score

The 24TB capacity, USB 3.0 connection, and included Rescue Data Recovery Services make this desktop drive the choice for a Time Machine backup set that needs 24TB.

Seagate Expansion
Capacity
24TB
Weight
2.95 lb
Warranty
1 Year Limited

This Seagate Expansion drive is a desktop hard drive with 24576 GB of installed capacity, listed as 24TB. It connects by USB 3.0 and uses a power adapter and USB cable. It recognizes Windows and Mac computers automatically, and reformatting is required for use with Time Machine. Drag-and-drop file saving works right out of the box. The drive includes Rescue Data Recovery Services and a 1 Year Limited warranty. Its weight is 2.95 lb, so it suits a fixed desk position rather than travel. The 24TB capacity suits a Time Machine backup set that keeps growing.

Choose it if

  • Your Time Machine backup set needs 24TB of installed capacity
  • You keep the drive on a desk with its power adapter connected

Consider another if

  • You want a portable drive at 0.29 lb rather than a 2.95 lb desktop drive
  • You need a 3-year limited warranty rather than a 1 Year Limited warranty
2
Second Pick

WD 2TB My Passport Ultra

9.6PCKitHQ
score

The 2TB capacity, USB-C and USB 3.1 compatibility, and Mac formatting make this portable drive a compact Mac option at 2TB.

WD 2TB My Passport Ultra
Capacity
2TB
Interface
USB 3.1
Weight
0.29 lb
Warranty
3-year limited warranty

This Western Digital drive is a portable hard drive with 2048 GB of installed capacity, listed as 2TB. It is formatted for Mac and connects by USB-C, with USB 3.1 compatibility. Password protection uses 256-bit AES hardware encryption, and the included backup software defends against ransomware. The refined metal cover gives the drive a distinct finish, and the drive weighs 0.29 lb. The warranty is a 3-year limited warranty. The 2TB capacity suits a backup set that fits within that figure, and the drive is formatted for Mac. Business and personal use fit this drive, and the silver finish matches the refined metal cover. It suits a Mac owner who wants a portable drive that works for work files and personal files alike.

Choose it if

  • Your backup set fits within 2TB of capacity
  • You want a 0.29 lb portable drive with a refined metal cover

Consider another if

  • You need the 24TB capacity of the Seagate Expansion drive
  • You need the 4TB capacity of the Seagate Expansion Desktop
3
Also Consider

WD 2TB My Passport

9.4PCKitHQ
score

The 2TB capacity, Mac-ready design, and USB-C compatibility make this navy portable drive another Mac option at the same capacity.

WD 2TB My Passport
Capacity
2TB
Interface
USB 3.1
Weight
0.26 lb
Warranty
3-year manufacturer's limited warranty

This Western Digital drive is a portable hard drive with 2048 GB of installed capacity, listed as 2TB. It is designed for Mac and is Mac-ready with USB-C compatibility and USB 3.1 support. Password protection is included, and the device management software defends against ransomware. The slim durable design suits carrying files with you, and the drive weighs 0.26 lb. Its warranty is a 3-year manufacturer's limited warranty. The 2TB capacity suits a backup set that fits within that figure. The navy finish distinguishes it from the silver Ultra drive at the same capacity.

Choose it if

  • You want a slim durable design for carrying files with you
  • Your backup set fits within 2TB of capacity

Consider another if

  • You need the 24TB capacity of the Seagate Expansion drive
  • You need the 4TB capacity of the Seagate Expansion Desktop
4
Also Consider

Seagate Expansion Desktop

9.2PCKitHQ
score

The 4TB capacity and USB 3.0 connection make this desktop drive a middle-capacity option for a Time Machine backup set.

Seagate Expansion Desktop
Capacity
4TB
Interface
USB 3.0
Weight
2.09 lb

This Seagate Expansion Desktop drive has 4096 GB of installed capacity, listed as 4TB. It connects by USB 3.0 and uses a power supply and USB cable. It recognizes Windows and Mac computers automatically, and reformatting is required for Time Machine. Drag-and-drop file saving starts immediately when the drive is plugged in. Fast file transfers run over the USB 3.0 connection. Its weight is 2.09 lb, so it suits a fixed desk position rather than travel.

Choose it if

  • Your Time Machine backup set needs more than 2TB of capacity
  • You keep the drive on a desk with its power supply connected

Consider another if

  • You need the 24TB capacity of the Seagate Expansion drive
  • You want a portable drive at 0.29 lb rather than a 2.09 lb desktop drive

Make the choice for your setup

Match capacity to your backup set

Start with the installed capacity of each drive. The Seagate Expansion 24TB drive has 24576 GB, the Seagate Expansion Desktop has 4096 GB, and each Western Digital drive has 2048 GB. A Time Machine backup set that grows over time needs room beyond its current size, so compare the set you keep today against the installed figure of the drive you choose. The 2TB drives suit a backup set that fits within 2048 GB. The 4TB drive suits a set that passes 2048 GB and fits within 4096 GB. The 24TB drive suits a set that passes 4096 GB. Do not treat the 6TB figure in the Western Digital My Passport for Mac description as installed capacity; that figure describes a range of capacities, while the installed capacity of the named drive is 2048 GB.

Check the connection and the Mac setup

The Western Digital drives connect by USB-C with USB 3.1 compatibility, and the Ultra is formatted for Mac while the My Passport for Mac is Mac-ready. The Western Digital My Passport Ultra for Mac adds password protection with 256-bit AES hardware encryption. The Seagate drives connect by USB 3.0 and recognize Windows and Mac computers automatically, and both need reformatting for Time Machine. The Seagate Expansion 24TB drive uses a power adapter and USB cable, and the Seagate Expansion Desktop uses a power supply and USB cable. Confirm the connection on your Mac before you choose, and keep the reformatting step in mind for the Seagate drives. The My Passport for Mac includes device management software with defense against ransomware, and both Western Digital drives carry a 3-year limited warranty. A related shortlist covers the Best Portable External SSD.

Weigh portability against desktop capacity

The two Western Digital drives weigh 0.29 lb and 0.26 lb, so they travel with a laptop. The Seagate Expansion Desktop weighs 2.09 lb and the Seagate Expansion 24TB drive weighs 2.95 lb, and both need a power supply or power adapter. A portable drive suits a backup set you carry between places, while a desktop drive suits a backup set that stays beside one Mac. The 2TB portable drives hold a backup set that fits within 2048 GB. The 4TB desktop drive holds a set that fits within 4096 GB. The 24TB desktop drive holds a set that fits within 24576 GB. Choose the weight and the capacity together, not one alone.

Comparing more options? See Best External Hard Drive.

FAQ: External Hard Drive for Time Machine Backup

What installed capacity does each drive have?

The Seagate Expansion 24TB External Hard Drive HDD has 24576 GB of installed capacity. The Seagate Expansion Desktop has 4096 GB, and each Western Digital drive has 2048 GB. The 24TB drive connects by USB 3.0 and needs reformatting for Time Machine.

Do the Seagate drives work with Time Machine?

Both Seagate drives recognize Windows and Mac computers automatically, and both need reformatting for use with Time Machine. The Seagate Expansion 24TB drive connects by USB 3.0, and the Seagate Expansion Desktop connects by USB 3.0. Reformat the drive before you set up the Time Machine backup.

Which drives are formatted for Mac?

The Western Digital My Passport Ultra for Mac is formatted for Mac. The Western Digital My Passport for Mac is designed for Mac and is Mac-ready. The Seagate drives recognize Windows and Mac computers automatically and need reformatting for Time Machine.

More guides for your setup