Best External Hard Drive for Mac Time Machine (2026): 6 Picks Compared
Choose the Seagate Expansion 24TB External Hard Drive HDD if you want 24TB of desktop backup storage for Time Machine after reformatting. It recognizes Windows and Mac computers automatically and saves files with drag-and-drop ease. The WD My Passport for Mac adds a Mac-ready 5TB design with USB-C, while the WD My Passport Ultra for Mac adds formatting for Mac with USB-C and USB 3.1.
Your shortlist at a glance
PCKitHQ scores range from 9.2 to 9.8. See how we pick.
| Product and key specifications | Score and retailer |
|---|---|
01![]() | 9.8PCKitHQ scoreView on Amazon |
02![]() | 9.7PCKitHQ scoreView on Amazon |
03![]() | 9.6PCKitHQ scoreView on Amazon |
04![]() | 9.4PCKitHQ scoreView on Amazon |
05![]() | 9.3PCKitHQ scoreView on Amazon |
06![]() | 9.2PCKitHQ scoreView on Amazon |
A closer look at each configuration
Seagate Expansion
score
24TB of desktop storage with drag-and-drop saving and Rescue Data Recovery Services defines this Seagate Expansion drive.

- Capacity
- 24TB
- Weight
- 2.95 lb
- Warranty
- 1 Year Limited
This Seagate Expansion 24TB External Hard Drive HDD is a desktop drive that plugs in with a power adapter and a USB cable. It saves files with drag-and-drop ease right out of the box and recognizes Windows and Mac computers automatically for simple setup. Reformatting is required for use with Time Machine, so format the drive before the first backup. The drive holds 24TB of content and weighs 2.95 lb, so it sits on a desk rather than traveling in a bag. Rescue Data Recovery Services come included beside a 1 Year Limited warranty.
Choose it if
- You want 24TB of desktop backup storage
- You back up a Mac with Time Machine
Consider another if
- You need a portable drive like the WD My Passport
- You need a 3-year warranty like the WD My Passport
WD 5TB My Passport
score
A Mac-ready 5TB design with USB-C, password protection, and ransomware defense defines this WD My Passport for Mac.

- Capacity
- 5TB
- Interface
- USB 3.1/USB 3.0
- Weight
- 0.46 lb
- Warranty
- 3-year manufacturer's limited warranty
This WD 5TB My Passport for Mac is designed for Mac and comes Mac-ready with USB-C compatibility for effortless connectivity. Its slim durable design carries important files on the go, and the drive holds 5TB of photos, videos, music, and documents. Backup software with defense against ransomware backs up smarter, and password protection guards the files. The drive connects through USB 3.1 and USB 3.0, weighs 0.46 lb, and carries a 3-year manufacturer's limited warranty.
Choose it if
- You want a drive designed for Mac
- You want USB-C for effortless connectivity
Consider another if
- You need 24TB like the Seagate Expansion drive
- You need the 2TB size of the Canvio Flex
WD 5TB My Passport Ultra
score
A 5TB drive formatted for Mac with USB-C, USB 3.1, and 256-bit AES encryption defines this WD Ultra for Mac.

- Capacity
- 5TB
- Interface
- USB-C and USB 3.1
- Weight
- 0.51 lb
- Warranty
- 3-year limited warranty
This WD My Passport Ultra for Mac holds 5TB and comes formatted for Mac, so it starts without extra setup. It connects through USB-C and USB 3.1, and its refined metal cover carries a silver finish. Password protection with 256-bit AES hardware encryption guards the files on the drive. Backup software with defense against ransomware is part of the package. The drive weighs 0.51 lb and carries a 3-year limited warranty.
Choose it if
- You want a drive formatted for Mac
- You want password protection with hardware encryption
Consider another if
- You need 24TB like the Seagate Expansion drive
- You need the 2TB size of the Canvio Flex
Toshiba Canvio Flex
score
A 2TB exFAT drive with USB-C and USB-A cables for PC, Mac, and tablet defines this Toshiba Canvio Flex.

- Capacity
- 2TB
- Interface
- USB-C USB 3.0
- Weight
- 0.33 lb
- Warranty
- 3 year limited manufacturer
This Toshiba Canvio Flex 2TB Portable External Hard Drive is designed for PC, Mac, and Tablet and comes formatted exFAT for cross-device compatibility. It is USB-C ready and USB 3.0 compatible, and the versatile design includes USB-C and USB-A cables in the box. The drive holds 2TB and weighs 0.33 lb, so it travels light. It carries a 3 year limited manufacturer warranty. Check compatibility at Toshiba's Consumer HDD website.
Choose it if
- You want a drive for PC, Mac, and tablet
- You want USB-C and USB-A cables included
Consider another if
- You need 5TB like the WD My Passport for Mac
- You need 24TB like the Seagate Expansion drive
Seagate Portable
score
A 1TB portable drive with USB 3.0, drag-and-drop backup, and an 18 inch cable defines this Seagate Portable.

- Capacity
- 1TB
- Interface
- USB 3.0
- Weight
- 0.42 lb
- Warranty
- 1 Year Limited
This Seagate Portable drive holds 1TB of content and works with Windows or Mac computers, so backup is a drag-and-drop task. Reformatting may be required for Mac, so check the format before the first backup. It connects through USB 3.0 with an included 18 inch cable and provides plug and play simplicity. The drive weighs 0.42 lb and carries a 1 Year Limited warranty beside its 1-Year Rescue Service.
Choose it if
- Your files fit within 1TB of storage
- You want drag-and-drop backup for a Mac
Consider another if
- You need 5TB like the WD My Passport for Mac
- You need the 3-year warranty of the WD Ultra
Toshiba Canvio Basics
score
A 1TB plug-and-play drive with USB 3.0 and no power cord defines this Toshiba Canvio Basics.

- Capacity
- 1TB
- Interface
- USB 3.0
- Weight
- 0.33 lb
- Warranty
- 1 year standard limited warranty
This Toshiba Canvio Basics 1TB Portable External Hard Drive adds storage to a PC and other compatible devices with plug-and-play ease and no software to install. It connects through USB 3.0 and USB 2.0 with no external AC power cord needed. The sleek profile design carries a matte, smudge-resistance finish. The drive comes pre-formatted NTFS for Windows PC, and reformatting is required for Mac computers. It weighs 0.33 lb and carries a 1 year standard limited warranty.
Choose it if
- You want plug-and-play storage with no software
- You want a drive with no power cord
Consider another if
- You need 5TB like the WD My Passport for Mac
- You need Mac formatting like the WD Ultra
Make the choice for your setup
Choose the capacity for Time Machine
The Seagate Expansion holds 24TB, the WD My Passport for Mac and the WD My Passport Ultra for Mac each hold 5TB, the Toshiba Canvio Flex holds 2TB, and the Seagate Portable and the Toshiba Canvio Basics each hold 1TB. Time Machine backups grow as files change, so a larger drive holds more backup history. A 24TB desktop drive suits a large library, while a 1TB portable drive suits a smaller set of files. Match the capacity to the files you keep and the history you want to keep. Check the size of your current library before choosing between the 24TB, 5TB, 2TB, and 1TB options in this guide.
Check formatting and Time Machine setup
The WD My Passport Ultra for Mac comes formatted for Mac, and the WD My Passport for Mac is Mac-ready. The Seagate Expansion recognizes Windows and Mac computers automatically, but reformatting is required for use with Time Machine. The Seagate Portable notes that reformatting may be required for Mac. The Toshiba Canvio Flex comes formatted exFAT for cross-device compatibility. The Toshiba Canvio Basics comes pre-formatted NTFS for Windows PC, and reformatting is required for Mac computers. A drive formatted for Mac starts without extra setup, while a drive that needs reformatting takes an extra step before the first backup. Match the format to your Mac before the first Time Machine backup. If that fits your setup better, see our guide to the Best External Backup Drive.
Compare weight, warranty, and protection
The Toshiba Canvio Flex and the Toshiba Canvio Basics weigh 0.33 lb, the Seagate Portable weighs 0.42 lb, the WD My Passport for Mac weighs 0.46 lb, the WD My Passport Ultra for Mac weighs 0.51 lb, and the Seagate Expansion weighs 2.95 lb. The WD My Passport for Mac carries a 3-year manufacturer's limited warranty, the WD My Passport Ultra for Mac carries a 3-year limited warranty, and the Toshiba Canvio Flex carries a 3 year limited manufacturer warranty. The Seagate Expansion carries a 1 Year Limited warranty, the Seagate Portable carries a 1 Year Limited warranty, and the Toshiba Canvio Basics carries a 1 year standard limited warranty. The WD My Passport Ultra for Mac adds password protection with 256-bit AES hardware encryption, and the Seagate Expansion adds Rescue Data Recovery Services.
For a wider shortlist, start with Best External Hard Drive.
FAQ: External Hard Drive for Mac Time Machine
Which drives here hold 5TB of storage?
The WD My Passport for Mac and the WD My Passport Ultra for Mac each hold 5TB. The Seagate Expansion holds 24TB, the Toshiba Canvio Flex holds 2TB, and the Seagate Portable and the Toshiba Canvio Basics each hold 1TB. The 5TB drives suit a large photo or video library.
Which drives here need reformatting for Time Machine?
The Seagate Expansion needs reformatting for use with Time Machine. The Seagate Portable notes that reformatting may be required for Mac, and the Toshiba Canvio Basics needs reformatting for Mac computers. The WD My Passport Ultra for Mac comes formatted for Mac, and the WD My Passport for Mac is Mac-ready.
What warranty terms do these drives carry?
The WD My Passport for Mac carries a 3-year manufacturer's limited warranty, the WD My Passport Ultra for Mac carries a 3-year limited warranty, and the Toshiba Canvio Flex carries a 3 year limited manufacturer warranty. The Seagate Expansion and the Seagate Portable carry 1 Year Limited warranties, and the Toshiba Canvio Basics carries a 1 year standard limited warranty.



